All melee army = all your troops get hit by their archers and slingers before they even swing a sword. You will lose the war of attrition.
Since you didn't specify a specific author or website, I will provide a comprehensive review of the standard "Barbarian Village" mechanics and strategies currently used in . ikariam barbarian village attack guide
Every island you colonize features its own unique Barbarian Village. This village is private to you; no other player can raid your barbarians or steal your progress. Scaling Difficulty: All melee army = all your troops get
Attacking Barbarian Villages in Ikariam requires strategy, preparation, and attention to detail. By following this guide, you'll be well-equipped to successfully conquer these villages, gather valuable resources, and progress in the game. Happy raiding! gather valuable resources